失效模式(FMEA详解)

《失效模式(FMEA详解)》由会员分享，可在线阅读，更多相关《失效模式(FMEA详解)（31页珍藏版）》请在装配图网上搜索。

1、Delta Confidential,,FMEA,,Failure Mode and Effects Analysis,,失效模式與效應分析,1 of 33,FMEA 意義說明,,FMEA,是不良,預防的工具,,,是一種,,有條理程序可藉由一張包含所有,,的失效模式的表,,,並以數據來表,,示風險的大小和預先採取預防改,,善措施。,,,,2 of 33,導入FMEA的優點,,Team work,方式提高部門或,Function,間連繫溝通,,,共同預防改善問題,,,,腦力激盪方式,,,讓每一成員在同一議題上發揮想像力,,,經由有系統整合,,提出有效之預防改善對策,,,徹底了解產品功能架構圖或產

2、品製造組合流程圖,,,以魚骨圖分析方式列出失效模式每一種可能因子,,,以失效樹分析,(FTA),方法了解產品失效模式各種組合型式,,,,把失效模式量化針對,Top Failure Mode,優先採取對策預防,,,確保所有想像得到失效模式和影響,,,在正常操作情況之下均被考慮到,,,藉由過去的資料給未來參考,,,協助分析失效的範圍和影響性,,提供設計產品或製程管制預防採取對策時使用,3 of 33,,Core team,:,列出與,FMEA team,相關人員名字,,,部門與職責,,,,Failure mode,:,失效模式種類,,,,Effect,:,失效後對產品產生影響,,,,Cause,:

3、,造成失效模式之原因,,,,Severity,:,失效模式發生之嚴重程度等級,(1,～,10),,,,Occurrence,:,失效模式之發生頻度等級,(1,～,10),,,,Detection,:,失效模式發生可被偵測程度等級,(1,～,10),,,,RPN,: Risk Priority Number,指評估風險及優先處理指數,,是,Severity * Occurrence * Detection,之乘積,,,,FTA,:Fault tree analysis,是失效樹分析是導果為因由頂端,,事件利用邏輯,(OR,或,AND),持續分析第,1.2…,層直,,至真正,Root cause,

4、將這些原因謀求徹底改善,FMEA相關名詞解說,4 of 33,,QFD,: Quality Function Deployment,,,DOE,: Design of Experiments,,,VOC,: Voice of Customer,,,VOE,: Voice of Engineering,,,SOP,: Standard Operation Procedure,,,SIP,: Standard Inspection Procedure,,,FRACAS,: Failure Report Analysis and,,Corrective Action System,,,SPC,: S

5、tatistic Process Control,,,TQM,: Total Quality Management,,,DVT,: Design Valuation Test,,,MTBF,: Mean Time Between Failure,FMEA書籍相關名詞解說,5 of 33,FMEA 型式,SYSTEM,,SFMEA,,,Design,,DFMEA,,,* Component,,,* Unit,,,* Module,,,Process,,PFMEA,,,Machine,,MFMEA,,,Equipment,,EFMEA,,,Service,,SFMEA,6 of 33,組成FMEA

6、團隊,設計 FMEA 流程(DFMEA),蒐集資料,完成FMEA執行方案,系統特性,系統功能,硬品架構,分析失效模式,分析設計管制方法,分析失效原因,分析失效效應,分析嚴重度,計算關鍵指數,分析發生率,分析難檢度,建議改正行動,決定關鍵性,,失效模式,設計審查,,評估資料,設計改善,,參考資料,可靠度分析,,參考資料,標準檢驗,,程序資料,教育訓練,,參考資料,失效報告。分析,,與改正作業系統,,(FRACAS),設計改善,撰寫報告,維護度分析,,參考資料,7 of 33,組成FMEA團隊,製程 FMEA 流程(PFMEA),蒐集資料,完成FMEA執行方案,定義製造流程,分析產品特性,分析製程

7、特性,分析失效模式,分析現行管制方法,分析失效原因,分析失效效應,分析嚴重度,計算關鍵指數,分析發生率,分析難檢度,建議改正行動,決定關鍵性,,失效模式,設計審查,,評估資料,設計改善,,參考資料,新製程設計,,參考資料,標準檢驗,,程序資料,教育訓練,,參考資料,失效報告。分析,,與改正作業系統,,(FRACAS),製程改善,檢驗程序改善,撰寫報告,8 of 33,FMEA 實施步驟,1,.,決定FMEA 對象,,2,. 成立&組成FMEA team members,,3,. 收集&準備相似產品之歷史資料,,4,. 列出產品方塊圖或製程流程圖,,5,. 列出Failure mode 各種可能

8、情況,,6,. 列出Failure mode 對產品/機器之,,影響 (Effect),,7,. 魚骨圖分析造成此Failure mode,,之可能原因 (Cause),,8,. 根據相關產品之歷史資料定義出,,Severity /Occurrence,,Detection 之等級,,9,. 根據 S/O/D 的定義定出每個,,Failure mode 之 S/O/D 值,,10,. 列出相似Model 目前採行之Action,11,. 計算出 RPN=S*O*D 值,,12,. 取 RPN 值 ≧100 (值大小需定義) or Top 20% 優先採取對策,,13,. 針對 RPN 值超

9、出上述定之項目提,,出Action 再改善,,14,. 定出 Action item 之 owner 及完成,,日期,,15,. Action 切入後檢視其效果及切入時,,間點,,16,. 重新計算Action 後之 RPN 值,,17,. 若 RPN 值未達定義要求 RPN,,≧100 or Top 20% 回覆到 item,,13 重提 Action,,18,. 若 RPN 達到要求完成 FMEA 表格,9 of 33,FMEA Team Members,,DFMEA (Design),,,,Chairperson,,* Program Manager,(PM),,* Electronic

10、 Engineer,(EE),,* Mechanical Engineer,(ME),,* Quality Engineer,(QE),,* Quality Engineer,(QA),,,* Manufacturing,(MES),,Support Team,,* Purchasing (Buyer) if Need,,,,PFMEA (Process),,,,Chairperson,,* Program Manager,(PM),,* Quality Engineer,(QA),,* Industry Engineer,(IE),,* Mechanical Engineer,(MFG ME

11、),,* Test Engineer,(TE),,* Manufacture Supervisor,(MFG),,* Electronic Engineer,(EE),if Need,,* Mechanical Engineer,(ME),if Need,,,10 of 33,Failure Mode Fishbone Analysis,Hi-Pot 不良,,Failure,,Mode,,(Defect),錫面,組立,加工不良,第一層分析,,Workmanship,第二層分析,第三層分析,第四層分析,正面裝插,零件插歪斜,零件面有異物,無線尾,零件變形,零件碰case,零件相碰,第一層分析,,

12、Material,變壓器不良,PCB不良,Y電容不良,Power Cable破,EMI不良,Case不良,第二層分析,第三層分析,絕緣tape破,引腳超出base,焊點過大造成tape破,儀器設備,儀器設定,Layout 安規距離不夠,Arcing 規定過嚴,零件間安規距離不足,第一層分析,,Design,第一層分析,,Test,第二層分析,第三層分析,第二層分析,第三層分析,鎖螺絲過長,套管短,零件本体大Layout 面積小,測試條件設錯,O/I寫錯,測試線接錯,11 of 33,Hi-Pot,,Failure,,Analysis,Fault Tree Analysis For Hi-Pot

13、 Failure,5.,,板,,邊,,零,,件,,傾,,斜,,踫,,Case,,,造,,成,,安,,規,,距,,離,,不,,夠,b.,,Socket,,上,,Y,,電,,容,,線,,腳,,靠,,近,,馬,,口,,鐵,a.,,Socket,,FG,,線,,漏,,焊,Process,4.,,錫,,面,,3.,,正,,面,,裝,,插,2.,,組,,立,1.,,加,,工,,不,,良,d.,,錫,,面,,短,,路,,︵,,錫,,珠,,,錫,,渣,,︶,c.,,線,,腳,,過,,長,b.,,漏,,焊,,︵,,Y,,電,,容,,︶,a.,,異,,物,c.,,零,,件,,插,,歪,,斜,零,,件,,變,,形,

14、碰,,Case,碰,,T1,碰,,H/S,相,,互,,碰,,撞,b.,,零,,件,,面,,有,,異,,物,a.,,無,,線,,尾,h.,,鎖,,絲,,未,,鎖,,緊,,或,,漏,,鎖,g.,,掉,,金,,屬,,物,,進,,產,,品,f.,,絕,,緣,,片,,放,,置,,不,,當,,或,,漏,,裝,d.,,PCB,,沒,,有,,卡,,到位,c.,,組,,立,,時,,,B+,,B-,,線,,壓,,傷,,壓,,破,,b.,,絕,,緣,,片,,膠,,布,,破,a.,,FG,,線,,有,,無,,Touch,,任,,何,,零,,件,c.,,膠,,布,,沒,,貼,,到,,位,Design,2.,,元,,件,

15、,之,,間,,安,,規,,距,,離,,不夠,,3.,,Arcing,,規,,格,,過,,嚴,c.,,鎖,,螺,,絲,,過,,長,b.,,套,,管,,短,a.,,原,,件,,本,,体,,大,,Layout,,面,,積,,小,4.,,板,,邊,,零,,件,,與,,Case,,安,,規,,距,,離,,不,,夠,,1.,,Layout,,安,,規,,距,,離,,不,,夠,Material,9.,,變,,壓,,器,,PFC,,︵,,電,,感,,︶,,8.,,膠,,雜,,質,,過,,多,7.,,Y,,電,,容,,不,,良,6.,,線,,材,,Power,,Cable,,破,5.,,PCB,4.,,EMI,

16、,Socket,3.,,Case,2.,,接,,地,,小,,黃,,豆,,電,,容,,耐,,壓,,不,,夠,,c.,,有,,毛,,刺,b.,,耳,,掛,,有,,凸,,起,a.,,碎,,屑,b.,,本,,身,,耐,,壓,,不,,夠,a.,,FG,,線,,氧,,化,,不,,吃,,錫,b.,,Trace,,近,,似,,短,,路,,或,,開,,路,a.,,PCB,,受,,潮,e.,,絕,,緣 Tape,,破,d.,,零,,件,,本,,体,,歪,,斜,c.,,焊,,點,,過,,大,,,造,,成,,錫,,間,,賜,,破,,絕,,緣,,層,b.,,引,,線,,腳,,超,,出,,base,a.,,絕,,緣,,膠

17、,,布,,位,,置,,不,,恰,,當,1.,,光,,藕,,合,,器,,不,,良,,e.,,O/I,,寫,,錯,,誤,Test,2.,,儀,,器,,設,,定,,1.,,儀,,器,c.,,測,,試,,條,,件,,設,,置,,錯,,誤,b.,,O/I,,寫,,錯,,誤,a.,,測,,試,,線,,接,,錯,b.,,儀,,器,,本,,身,,電,,壓,,頻,,率,,誤,,差,,大,a.,,接,,觸,,不,,良,f.,,本,,身,,繞,,線,,造,,成,,Arcing,,過,,大,其,,他,2.,,接,,地,,銅,,箔,,被,,燒,,斷,,3.,,接,,地,,跳,,線,,斷,,4.,,未,,依,,O/I,,

18、作,,業,1.,,Socket,,Y,,電,,容,,線,,腳,,斷,5.,,油,,墨,,,黑,,色,,Mark,,筆,,,在,,初,,級,,側,,導,,電,,,,12 of 33,Part Failure Mode Effect(s) Cause(s) Current or Action(s) to Area or Action(s),,Name,* Control(s)

19、 be taken Individual taken,,Function,responsible,,,Energy,,Management Cannot Customer Software,,Monitor dissatisfaction Failure,,Monitor Battery,,Battery alert Battery,,user of status connections,,spec. wrong,,,Incorrect,,battery used,

20、,,,,,Cannot Customer Software,,accurately dissatisfaction failure,,ID status,,Battery Connections,,damage spec. wrong,,,,Unable to,,detect,,battery,,Faults,,,,Severity,Severity,Occurrence,Occurrence,Detection,Detection,RPN,RPN,This column is used to list the par

21、t name,,and function. List all the functions for the functional block,FMEA 格式逐項解說,1.,2.,10.,4.,3.,5.,6.,8.,7.,9.,12.,11.,15.,14.,13.,13 of 33,Part Failure Mode Effect(s) Cause(s) Current or Action(s) to Area or Action(

22、s),,Name,* Control(s) be taken Individual taken,,Function,responsible,,,Energy,,Management Cannot Customer Software,,Monitor dissatisfaction Failure,,Monitor Battery,,Battery alert Battery,,user of status

23、 connections,,spec. wrong,,,Incorrect,,battery used,,,,,,Cannot Customer Software,,accurately dissatisfaction failure,,ID status,,Battery Connections,,damage spec. wrong,,,,Unable to,,detect,,battery,,Faults,,,,Severity,Severity,Occurrence,Occurrence,Detection,

24、Detection,RPN,RPN,2.,In the failure mode column, list each of the failure,,modes for the function.,FMEA 格式逐項解說,1.,10.,4.,3.,5.,6.,8.,7.,9.,12.,11.,15.,14.,13.,14 of 33,Part Failure Mode Effect(s) Cause(s) Current or Action(s) to

25、Area or Action(s),,Name,* Control(s) be taken Individual taken,,Function,responsible,,,Energy,,Management Cannot Customer Software,,Monitor dissatisfaction Failure,,Monitor Battery,,Battery alert Battery,

26、,user of status connections,,spec. wrong,,,Incorrect,,battery used,,,,,,Cannot Customer Software,,accurately dissatisfaction failure,,ID status,,Battery Connections,,damage spec. wrong,,,,Unable to,,detect,,battery,,Faults,,,,Severity,Severity,Occurre

27、nce,Detection,Detection,RPN,RPN,Occurrence,3.,List the effects of failure for each of the,,failure modes.,FMEA 格式逐項解說,1.,10.,4.,2.,5.,6.,8.,7.,9.,12.,11.,15.,14.,13.,15 of 33,Part Failure Mode Effect(s) Cause(s) Current or Action(s) to

28、 Area or Action(s),,Name,* Control(s) be taken Individual taken,,Function,responsible,,,Energy,,Management Cannot Customer Software,,Monitor dissatisfaction Failure,,Monitor Battery,,Battery alert B

29、attery,,user of status connections,,spec. wrong,,,Incorrect,,battery used,,,,,,Cannot Customer Software,,accurately dissatisfaction failure,,ID status,,Battery Connections,,damage spec. wrong,,,,Unable to,,detect,,battery,,Faults,,,,Severity,Severity,

30、Occurrence,Occurrence,Detection,Detection,RPN,RPN,For each one of the effects, list the,,severity (scale from 1 to 10),4.,FMEA 格式逐項解說,1.,10.,3.,2.,5.,6.,8.,7.,9.,12.,11.,15.,14.,13.,16 of 33,符合需求 ,,17 of 33,Part Failure Mode Effect(s) Cause(s) Current o

31、r Action(s) to Area or Action(s),,Name,* Control(s) be taken Individual taken,,Function,responsible,,,Energy,,Management Cannot Customer Software,,Monitor dissatisfaction Failure,,Monitor B

32、attery,,Battery alert Battery,,user of status connections,,spec. wrong,,,Incorrect,,battery used,,,,,,Cannot Customer Software,,accurately dissatisfaction failure,,ID status,,Battery Connections,,damage spec. wrong,,,,Unable to,,detect,,bat

33、tery,,Faults,,,,Severity,Severity,Occurrence,Occurrence,Detection,Detection,RPN,RPN,The Class column is optional. It is,,typically used if the severity is 9 or 10.,5.,FMEA 格式逐項解說,1.,10.,3.,2.,4.,6.,8.,7.,9.,12.,11.,15.,14.,13.,18 of 33,Part Failure Mode Effect(s) Cause(

34、s) Current or Action(s) to Area or Action(s),,Name,* Control(s) be taken Individual taken,,Function,responsible,,,Energy,,Management Cannot Customer Software,,Monitor dissatisfaction

35、 Failure,,Monitor Battery,,Battery alert Battery,,user of status connections,,spec. wrong,,,Incorrect,,battery used,,,,,,Cannot Customer Software,,accurately dissatisfaction failure,,ID status,,Battery Connections,,damage spec. wro

36、ng,,,,Unable to,,detect,,battery,,Faults,,,,Severity,Severity,Occurrence,Occurrence,Detection,Detection,RPN,RPN,,In the Cause column, list the causes,,for each failure mode,6.,FMEA 格式逐項解說,1.,10.,3.,2.,4.,5.,8.,7.,9.,12.,11.,15.,14.,13.,19 of 33,FMEA Model,Linking Failure Mode to,,Cause and Effect,Ca

37、use,Failure Mode,,(Defect),Effect,20 of 33,Part Failure Mode Effect(s) Cause(s) Current or Action(s) to Area or Action(s),,Name,* Control(s) be taken Individual t

38、aken,,Function,responsible,,,Energy,,Management Cannot Customer Software,,Monitor dissatisfaction Failure,,Monitor Battery,,Battery alert Battery,,user of status connections,,spec. wrong,,,Incorrect,,battery used,,,,,,Cannot Customer Software,,accura

39、tely dissatisfaction failure,,ID status,,Battery Connections,,damage spec. wrong,,,,Unable to,,detect,,battery,,Faults,,,,Severity,Severity,Occurrence,Occurrence,Detection,Detection,RPN,RPN,Estimate the likelihood of the,,“causes” happening on a “1 to,,10” scale. The hig

40、her the,,number the more likely the,,“causes” will occur.,7.,FMEA 格式逐項解說,1.,10.,3.,2.,4.,5.,8.,6.,9.,12.,11.,15.,14.,13.,21 of 33,22 of 33,Part Failure Mode Effect(s) Cause(s) Current or Action(s) to Area or Action(s),,

41、Name,* Control(s) be taken Individual taken,,Function,responsible,,,Energy,,Management Cannot Customer Software,,Monitor dissatisfaction Failure,,Monitor Battery,,Battery alert Battery,,user of status co

42、nnections,,spec. wrong,,,Incorrect,,battery used,,,,,,Cannot Customer Software,,accurately dissatisfaction failure,,ID status,,Battery Connections,,damage spec. wrong,,,,Unable to,,detect,,battery,,Faults,,,,Severity,Severity,Occurrence,Occurrence,Detection,Dete

43、ction,RPN,RPN,List the prevention, design validation/,,verification, or other activities which,,will assure the design adequacy for the,,failure mode and/or cause / mechanism,,under consideration.,,,Tests,,Design reviews,,,Mathematical studies,,,Fail/safe (Example: redundant,,power supplies),8.,FMEA

44、 格式逐項解說,1.,10.,3.,2.,5.,4.,6.,7.,9.,12.,11.,15.,14.,13.,23 of 33,Part Failure Mode Effect(s) Cause(s) Current or Action(s) to Area or Action(s),,Name,* Control(s) be taken

45、 Individual taken,,Function,responsible,,,Energy,,Management Cannot Customer Software,,Monitor dissatisfaction Failure,,Monitor Battery,,Battery alert Battery,,user of status connections,,spec. wrong,,,Incorrect,,battery used,,,,,,Cannot Customer

46、 Software,,accurately dissatisfaction failure,,ID status,,Battery Connections,,damage spec. wrong,,,,Unable to,,detect,,battery,,Faults,,,,Severity,Severity,Occurrence,Occurrence,Detection,Detection,RPN,RPN,Estimate the likelihood of the,,detection on a “1 to 10” sca

47、le. The lower the number the more likely the cause will be detected.,9.,FMEA 格式逐項解說,1.,10.,3.,2.,5.,4.,8.,7.,6.,12.,11.,15.,14.,13.,24 of 33,25 of 33,Part Failure Mode Effect(s) Cause(s) Current or Action(s) to Area or

48、 Action(s),,Name,* Control(s) be taken Individual taken,,Function,responsible,,,Energy,,Management Cannot Customer Software,,Monitor dissatisfaction Failure,,Monitor Battery,,Battery alert Battery,,user of status

49、 connections,,spec. wrong,,,Incorrect,,battery used,,,,,,Cannot Customer Software,,accurately dissatisfaction failure,,ID status,,Battery Connections,,damage spec. wrong,,,,Unable to,,detect,,battery,,Faults,,,,Severity,Severity,Occurrence,Occurrence,De

50、tection,Detection,RPN,RPN,RPN (Risk Priority Number) is the,,product of Severity, Occurrence,,,and Detection.,,,The higher the number, the higher the risk.,10.,FMEA 格式逐項解說,1.,2.,4.,3.,5.,6.,8.,7.,9.,12.,11.,15.,14.,13.,26 of 33,Part Failure Mode Effect(s) Cause(s)

51、 Current or Action(s) to Area or Action(s),,Name,* Control(s) be taken Individual taken,,Function,responsible,,,Energy,,Management Cannot Customer Software,,Monitor dissatisfaction

52、 Failure,,Monitor Battery,,Battery alert Battery,,user of status connections,,spec. wrong,,,Incorrect,,battery used,,,,,,Cannot Customer Software,,accurately dissatisfaction failure,,ID status,,Battery Connections,,damage spec. wrong,,,,Una

53、ble to,,detect,,battery,,Faults,,,,Severity,Severity,Occurrence,Occurrence,Detection,Detection,RPN,RPN,What actions need to be taken to prevent the Failure Mode?,,,If no action is taken, record “none”,11.,FMEA 格式逐項解說,1.,10.,4.,3.,5.,6.,8.,7.,9.,12.,2.,15.,14.,13.,27 of 33,Part Failur

54、e Mode Effect(s) Cause(s) Current or Action(s) to Area or Action(s),,Name,* Control(s) be taken Individual taken,,Function,responsible,,,Energy,,Management Cannot Customer

55、 Software,,Monitor dissatisfaction Failure,,Monitor Battery,,Battery alert Battery,,user of status connections,,spec. wrong,,,Incorrect,,battery used,,,,,,Cannot Customer Software,,accurately dissatisfaction failure,,ID status,,Battery Co

56、nnections,,damage spec. wrong,,,,Unable to,,detect,,battery,,Faults,,,,Severity,Severity,Occurrence,Occurrence,Detection,Detection,RPN,RPN,Assign appropriate individual, area,,,function or team.,,Set a realistic target for completion,,Target date could be established,,by development program

57、,12.,FMEA 格式逐項解說,1.,10.,4.,3.,5.,6.,8.,7.,9.,2.,11.,15.,14.,13.,28 of 33,Part Failure Mode Effect(s) Cause(s) Current or Action(s) to Area or Action(s),,Name,* Control(s) be taken

58、 Individual taken,,Function,responsible,,,Energy,,Management Cannot Customer Software,,Monitor dissatisfaction Failure,,Monitor Battery,,Battery alert Battery,,user of status connections,,spec. wrong,,,Incorrect,,battery used,,,,,,Cannot Cust

59、omer Software,,accurately dissatisfaction failure,,ID status,,Battery Connections,,damage spec. wrong,,,,Unable to,,detect,,battery,,Faults,,,,Severity,Severity,Occurrence,Occurrence,Detection,Detection,RPN,RPN,List the results of the actions,,taken.,,,Always ent

60、er a reference such as data or test reports.,13.,FMEA 格式逐項解說,1.,10.,4.,3.,5.,6.,8.,7.,9.,12.,11.,15.,14.,2.,29 of 33,Part Failure Mode Effect(s) Cause(s) Current or Action(s) to Area or Action(s),,Name,*

61、 Control(s) be taken Individual taken,,Function,responsible,,,Energy,,Management Cannot Customer Software,,Monitor dissatisfaction Failure,,Monitor Battery,,Battery alert Battery,,user of status connections,,spec. wrong

62、,,,Incorrect,,battery used,,,,,,Cannot Customer Software,,accurately dissatisfaction failure,,ID status,,Battery Connections,,damage spec. wrong,,,,Unable to,,detect,,battery,,Faults,,,,Severity,Severity,Occurrence,Occurrence,Detection,Detection,RPN,RPN,When rea

63、ssessing SEVERITY, the,,only factors that will influence a,,change will be:,,new experience,,change in regulations,,design change,,change in customer priorities,14.,FMEA 格式逐項解說,1.,10.,4.,3.,5.,6.,8.,7.,9.,12.,11.,15.,2.,13.,30 of 33,Part Failure Mode Effect(s) Cause(s)

64、 Current or Action(s) to Area or Action(s),,Name,* Control(s) be taken Individual taken,,Function,responsible,,,Energy,,Management Cannot Customer Software,,Monitor dissatisfaction

65、 Failure,,Monitor Battery,,Battery alert Battery,,user of status connections,,spec. wrong,,,Incorrect,,battery used,,,,,,Cannot Customer Software,,accurately dissatisfaction failure,,ID status,,Battery Connections,,damage spec. wrong,,,,Unable to,,detect,,battery,,Faults,,,,Severity,Severity,Occurrence,Occurrence,Detection,Detection,RPN,RPN,If this RPN is not significantly less,,than previous, then ACTION taken,,has been ineffective.,15.,FMEA 格式逐項解說,1.,10.,4.,3.,5.,6.,8.,7.,9.,12.,11.,2.,14.,13.,31 of 33,